My wife and I test-drove the following cars, and ultimately ended up purchasing the Volt:
Acura TSX (both V6 and V4)
Acura TL
Nissan Maxima
Volkswagon CC
Volvo S60
We both felt that the Volt was the most fun to drive out of the group, and its pickup was a close contender for the Volvo S60. The Mrs. previously drove a Saab 9-3 SE, and though the Saab was quicker than the Volt, we both agree that the Volt is more than satisfactory.
When planning to buy a new car, we didn't even consider and electric (or hybrid) at first. Gas costs weren't a major concern. We just wanted something sporty, attractive, and with a good technology package around the $35-39K mark. With the $8000 in rebates for the Volt, it happened to satisfy all those requirements.
Would I take the Volt to a drag race? No. Can we do 140mph on a straightaway? No. But that's not really the goal of most cars in this price range.
I know the Volt is supposed to do something like a 9 second 0-60 time, but it's definitely less than that, and it will push you back in your seat when you juice it, either off the line or while merging.
As for the Leaf, that ugly pile of hippie sweat
is not in the same category as the Volt. IMO the Volt is a great car that just happens to have an electric drive.
-- Scott
Check out all my Volt-related posts:
http://s.co.tt/blog/blog/category/automotive-2/chevy-volt/