Jake, your making this hard because both are excellent, what are your needs? if you tow the avalanche is much better, some day you might have to tow something heavy , and its nice that the Chevy will tow 3000 more pounds.fuel economy there very close,the new redesigned 2007 avalanche, is much better looking,and way more fuel efficient than the older models. you get stump pulling V8 power with v6 fuel economy, the Honda is a little underpowered with its smaller v6, and has a shorter bed in back, and off road the Chevy is much better , Honda claims 23-25 mpg highway, but i know two people who own them and they get about 20-21 highway mpg and 14-16 city mpg.that's not good for a v6 and much lighter vehicle, also the Chevy has more room inside. and a better ride with a longer wheel base . I own both vehicles a 2005 Honda ex accord and a 2006 Chevy HD 2500 Lt3 duramax lbz diesel, i love them both, I give the edge to the new Chevy.